Nov
15
Structuralist Critique of Homologs and Non-Adaptive Order
“[T]hese apparently non-adaptive forms post an existential threat to the whole Darwinian and functionalist paradigm, because they imply that causal factors other than cumulative selection to serve functional ends must have played a crucial role in shaping living systems….” — Michael Denton, Evolution: Still a Theory in Crisis

Several months ago, I posted “Structuralism of the Gaps?”, in which I cited from Michael Denton’s Evolution: Still a Theory in Crisis (2016). In the first chapter, the author explained how he had been a convinced pan-adaptationist [who nevertheless] held to a strictly functionalist view of biological systems. His view then shifted (evolved?) when he realized that:
“[N]ot all features of living things are there to serve some adaptive purpose, and many of the taxa-defining novelties — such as the pentadactyl limb (Tetrapoda) or the concentric whorls of the flower (angiosperms) — give every appearance of being a-functional “primal patterns” which have never served any specific adaptive end.” [He continues this thought in the quote at the top of the page above.]
I stalled out after reading chapter 6, but there is great material to share from the intervening chapters. So, taking a little different approach than I normally would, I have decided to share from the final sections/summaries of chapters 3 and 4 below…
— — —
End of Chapter 3 (“The Hierarchy of Nature”)
In short, nature is still very much an empirical discontinuum of invariant unique forms, and there is no direct evidence that the “gaps” were ever closed by the functional continuums demanded by Darwinian theory. The fact that nearly all the authors cited above who confess to the reality of taxon-defining novelties are confirmed evolutionists — and are therefore intellectually predisposed to seek transitional forms — only serves to highlight the fact that the homologs are genuine novelties and the divisions they define are real!
This is not to claim that the Types were not actualized by natural processes. I believe they were and that the entire pattern of evolution was prefigured into the order of things from the beginning. Although I think the evidence is consistent with most of the novelties being achieved in a relatively saltational manner (as discussed in Chapter 6, section 6.4), typology does not demand absolute saltation, just that the Types (or more properly the homologs which define them) are a special set of robust natural forms or stable material systems, part of nature’s order from the moment of creation, to which the paths of evolution were inevitably drawn.
In Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, I wrote:
“The same deep homologous resemblance [novelties/synapopmorphies] which serves to link all the members of one class together into a natural group [or clade] also serves to distinguish that class unambiguously from all other classes. Similarly, the same hierarchic pattern which may be explained in terms of a theory of common descent, also, by its very nature, implies the existence of deep divisions in the order of nature. The same facts… which proclaim unity also proclaim division; while resemblance suggests evolution, division, especially where it appears profound, is counter-evidence against the whole notion of [gradual] transmutation.”
Thirty years later, despite the discovery of a huge number of new fossil forms and despite massive advances in every field of biology, especially evo-devo, it is still overwhelmingly true, as I insisted in Evolution and as Darwin confessed 150 years ago: “The distinctness of specific forms and their not being blended together by innumerable transitional links, is a very obvious difficulty.” Evolutionary novelties do exist and accounting for their causation is one of the major unsolved challenges of evolutionary biology.

Given their distinctness and the general absence of known intermediates leading to the homologs from antecedent structures, given their stunning invariance and constraining powers in so many diverse lineages, subject to all manner of contingencies not for a few years or a few centuries but for in many cases, vast periods of time, periods of time which represent a significant fraction of all cosmic time since the Big Bang, it is small wonder that pre-Darwinian biology saw the homologs as natural forms. How could mere contingent Darwinian assemblages, hobbled together to serve functions at specific times in phylogeny, possess such properties and exhibit such subsequent invariance?
In the next chapter, we will begin to explore the pervasiveness of non-adaptive order in nature and the additional challenge is poses to Darwinian explanations.
— — —
End of Chapter 4 (“Non-Adaptive Order”)
If, in Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, I had followed Owen, and pointed out that many of the defining homologs and Bauplans have never been shown to be specifically adaptive, it would have very greatly reinforced my critique. Although I read Gould’s “Spandrel paper” several years before Evolution was published, and although I had been puzzled at King’s College regarding the apparently non-adaptive enucleate red cell (see detailed discussion in Chapter 7), I was still basically a functionalist in 1985.
To be sure, the puzzle of homology was apparent even at medical school in Bristol, where the homologous structure of the hand and foot were obvious in the dissection room, and alluded to by David Yoffe, the then Professor of Anatomy.
But more than any other individual, it was Marcel-Paul (“Marco”) Schützenberger who started me on a thirty-year road to structuralism, by pointing out the abstract appearance of so many botanical forms during several visits to the Jardin de Plantes in Paris in the late 1980s.
I am somewhat embarrassed by my late discovery of the structuralist tradition and my failure to see through the pan-selectionist mirage to the deep layer of a-functional order which permeates living things, but I am in good company. Even [Stephen J.] Gould admitted to being “embarrassed by the fervor of [the] adaptationist convictions” he held early in his career, before he came to realize the significance of the structuralist tradition and the challenge it posed to the Darwinian framework. Gould wrote:

“Finally, if I could… wipe any of my publications off the face of the earth and out of all memory, I would gladly nominate my unfortunately rather popular review article on ‘Evolutionary paleontology and the science of form’… a ringing paean to selectionist absolutism, buttressed [by the idea that one] could… prove panadaptationism even for fossils that could not be run through the hoops of actual experiments.”
As I pointed out earlier, Gould described his appreciation later in his career for continental structuralist thought and for its “sheer intellectual power.”
In this chapter, we have seen that further undermining the Darwinian account of evolution is the fact that a great deal of organic order appears to be non-adaptive. This includes a great number of the taxa-defining Bauplans, such as the pentadactyl limb, the flower, the pattern of insect wing venation, and so forth. These Bauplans give not the slightest impression, nor is there any evidence for believing, that they serve in extant organisms, or ever did serve in extinct forms, any specific adaptive function, i.e., fitted actual species to actual environments. They therefore could not have originated as a result of gradual Darwinian adaptive evolution.
In the next chapter, we will examine the discoveries associated with the new field of evo-devo and see how these discoveries have undermined the Darwinian model as well.
— — —
I find Denton’s journey into structuralism quite interesting, as well as his discoveries and conclusions. I can see how some people might be skeptical of some of what he says, perhaps question or disagree with his conclusions. After all, Denton’s evidence and arguments all serve the case against panadaptationism via gradual Darwinian evolution, so those whose worldview is wrapped up in that will instinctively try to defend it.
But, there are those who are so sold out to Darwinian-type gradualism (even the “modern synthesis” version), that they will outright dismiss any such evidence and arguments against it. (Remember what Gould said just above?) And that is a sad commentary on Big Science — at least, those disciplines influenced by Darwin and his disciples.